REVIEW: Peanut Butter Playground Cake from Cold Stone Creamery

Spread the love

Last week I said I’d be reviewing the new cake from Cold Stone Creamery.

We had it for Father’s Day (except my mom who doesn’t like chocolate and my one daughter who gets sick from it.) Here are our thoughts.

My Dad:

  • Rich but delicious
  • Couldn’t really taste peanut butter
  • Don’t need a big piece since it’s so rich

My Husband:

  • Too rich
  • Otherwise Yummy
  • I’m not a big cake eater but I ate it all


  • Rich but still was able to eat a big piece
  • Loved the reese cup on top dipped in graham cracker crumbs
  • Why is the serving size 8 but there are 6 reese cups? Everyone should get one on their piece.
  • Oops. Forgot to let it sit out before eating, no wonder we can’t cut through it!
  • Very yummy but too expensive! I know it’s a speciality cake but ouch! Not for the empty of pocket. Maybe if it were bigger.
  • I tasted peanut butter on my first bite

My Daughter:

This picture says it all.

      *Disclosure: I received the product(s) mentioned above free of charge by the company or PR representative for evaluation purposes. No other compensation was provided. See my Disclosure Policy for more information. 

      Speak Your Mind